Category Archives: Blogs (Articles)

papers, lecture texts, book reviews, press reports , etc., mostly on science and education policy , history of science, ancient history

Raja Ramanna: Reminiscences

RAJA RAMANNA
Ramanna was appointed defence minister by VP Singh. As a balancing act MGK Menon was made science minister. (Both held independent charge but had the rank of aminister of state.) In 1990, Survey of India DehraDun organized a meeting on the occasion of George Everest’s 200th birthday. Defence Minister was give the opening address and I was reading a paper. Those were the days of Mandal unrest. Since I knew Ramanna from his Bangalore days I asked him if I could come with him in the military helicopter. Most graciously he agreed pointing out that I would have to pay the prescribed charges. I was parked at Delhi. There was a phone call saying Ramanna speaking. For a while I got confused thinking the call was from his office. A military jeep was sent to where I was staying to bring me to his office. Given the general unrest, arrival of a military jeep and my being whisked off became a topic of local interest. VP Singh had called a meeting of the Council of Ministers. Could I read Ramanna’s address? I took a midnight taxi and brought his address to DehraDun. The government fell soon thereafter.
Ramanna had a tremendous sense of humour. One of his regrets was that the people he met in the public life did not quiteappreciate it, Worse, they took offence.

RAJA RAMANNA (contd)
Ramanna was chairing a lecture in IISc campus ( in the auditorium near the main gate). After the lecture an oldish man stood up to ask a question or make a point. He bagan: First of all I wish to complement the learned speaker on his brilliant and lucid presentation …blah-blah. Finally he decided to come to the pointby saying However,
By this time Ramanna had run out of patience:You have spoken enough. Now sit down!

Ramanna has a genuine curiosity about things and welcomed addition or correction to his knowledge base. It is well known that the trigonometrical sine originated in India whee the term used in Sanskrit was jya. How does jya become sine, he wanted to know. I did not know. I spent some time in the library and answered his question the next time we met. Jya was rendered as jaib in Arabic. Jaib was an existing word in Arabic meaning folds of a derss. Jaib was literally translated as sinus in Latin

In an inaugural address Ramanna attributed the calculation of the highest peak in the Himalayas to Everest’s tenure as Surveyor General . During the tea break I explained to him that the peak was calculated after Everest had retired and it was named in his honour by his successor, Andrew Waugh. He appreciated the information, for future use.

Water water everywhere, but not for you

Sewerage pipe in our house in Chandigarh is blocked. A sanitary worker has been called and is still at work . When he came in he asked: Can I get a glass of water? Of course you can get a glass of water. What else these hot days if not water? After a short pause he says: Just now I was in a house in the neighbourhood. I asked for water. Nobody said anything, but there was such a long unconfortable silence that I decided not to repeat the request.

Frauds in Indian scientific research

Images are an integral part of experimental biomedical research. Increased sophistication of detection techniques has made it easier than ever before to detect unethical image processing. Many old frauds that were considered safe in their time can be exposed now. There are many more skeletons waiting to tumble out from the cupboard.

The UGC and other regulatory bodies are solely responsible for bringing about a precipitous decline in Indian scientific research. There is now an unhealthy obsession with research and research degrees. Science today is a child of high technology. No policy-maker in India has ever asked the question: Given the standards of school and college education and absence of industrial prowess, how much high-quality research can India sustain? If unrealistic demands are made on the system, only fake publications and bogus degrees can be the result.

https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/comment/frauds-in-indian-scientific-research/789742.html#disqus_thread